0%

When should you switch CMS?

Most people ask the wrong question first. The interesting one is not which CMS is best – it is whether the CMS is even the problem.

The question "should we get a new CMS?" usually arrives before the diagnosis. Somebody has become frustrated – the editorial team, the developers, management – and the frustration gets translated into a platform question quickly, because that is the easiest thing to act on. A new CMS is a project with a start and an end. Working out what is actually wrong is harder, and it often gets skipped.

First: what actually hurts?

What people call "a CMS problem" is usually one of three different things, and each needs a different fix.

  1. A maintenance problem. Old plugins, no updates, code nobody dares touch, no version control. That is not the platform's fault – it is eight years where nobody cleaned up. The fix is cleanup, not a new system.
  2. An implementation problem. The platform is fine, but this particular build is not – a product structure that was never thought through, an integration glued together at the last minute, a content hierarchy that made sense for the first project and not for what the site has become since. The fix is rebuilding the part that is broken, not replacing the foundation.
  3. A platform problem. This is the rarest of the three, and the strongest argument for a new CMS: the way the platform models data and handles workflows no longer fits what the business needs. Not because anyone implemented it badly – but because what the business needs to do does not fit the way the platform thinks about content. Sometimes the answer is not a different CMS, but a different architecture around the existing one – see WordPress vs. headless.

A platform problem can also be more fundamental: the system is no longer maintained or security-patched, and staying on it is no longer safe.

The three get mixed up constantly, and that is expensive. A maintenance problem fixed with a migration is money spent on the wrong thing – and a real platform problem met with yet another cleanup is time that just postpones the same conversation a year later.

When the CMS is not the problem

Most "we should switch CMS" conversations start here, without anyone noticing. Plugins that overlap because different developers solved the same problem twice over eight years. A theme nobody dares update. No version control, so nobody knows what has actually changed since last time. None of that is a sign the platform is wrong – it is a sign the system has never had the maintenance it needed. I wrote the full list in The art of inheriting a WordPress installation; I will not repeat it here.

When the CMS has actually become the problem

A real platform problem looks different. It shows up when the way the system organises content and data no longer fits what the business needs to do. If a new feature keeps requiring another exception, another layer, or the same information stored in more than one place, it is worth asking whether the problem can still be solved within the existing platform.

The technical side is only half the story. A system can work flawlessly on a technical level and still be wrong, if the editorial team has outgrown it. If an editor has to know internal IDs to fix a page, copy the same content into three different places, or call a developer to create a new content type, the problem is not necessarily performance or old code. It is a sign that the system's workflows no longer match the organisation using it every day. Whether that calls for a new CMS or a better implementation of the existing one is exactly what needs working out.

What actually gets better?

Before deciding on a migration, there should be a concrete answer to: once we are done, we will be able to ___, which we cannot today.

"We get a newer codebase" is not an answer that carries a project of that size. "The editorial team can manage several markets without developer help" is. "Product data gets one model instead of living in three different places in three different ways" is too. The difference is whether the answer points to something someone can concretely do afterwards – not whether the code looks nicer.

What you leave behind

"We'll just build it fresh" sounds simpler than it is. Underneath sits content, URLs, redirects, metadata, structured data, images and files, users, integrations, forms, tracking, consent, historical data, editorial workflows, permissions, and everything the search engines already know about the site.

But there is also something less visible than the list.

The old solution contains eight years of decisions.

Some of them are bad. Some of them solve problems nobody remembers existed – an exception for one client, a workaround for a system that no longer exists, a rule nobody can explain any more but that still solves a real problem. Do not move anything before you know why it is there.

A migration is a project of its own

A migration is not installing a different system and pouring the old content into it. The old system typically has to keep working while the new one is built, and changes to content and data do not stop in the meantime.

That is why a migration also needs a plan for the transition: what moves automatically, what has to be rebuilt, what has to be tested, and when the new system takes over. "We'll just move the content over" often turns out to be the smallest part of the work.

Fix it, or switch?

Not because the system is old. Not because the code is ugly. And not because a different CMS looks better in a demo.

Switch when the existing system is in the way of what the business or the editorial team needs to be able to do – and when it costs more to keep working around the limitations than it does to move.

If the problem is instead plugins, missing updates and code nobody dares touch any more, you may not need a new CMS.

You need to get a grip on what you already have. That is also the part of the work on CMS solutions I most often get called in for.

Tags_

Curriculum Vitae ↓

Profile Image

Paul Nybo Andersen

Profile_

49 years old, CTO, graphic designer, and full-stack developer (LAMP/LEMP) with 26 years of experience in developing digital solutions for a broad target group of companies.

Scroll to read more →

01_Services_

How I can help

I combine design and development into solutions that are simple to use and easy to maintain.

PHP • Laravel • MySQL • JavaScript

Web development

From database and backend to frontend, integrations and hosting.

UX • Figma • Prototypes • Testing

Web design & UX

Interface design that has to work for the user and the business alike.

Visual identity • Design systems • Print

Visual identity

Visual identity for companies that need to look like something you can rely on.

WordPress • Umbraco • Magento

CMS solutions

Content systems built for the people working in them every day.

Core Web Vitals • SEO • Caching

Performance & SEO

Websites that load quickly – including on a phone on a poor connection.

Architecture • Technology choice • Sparring

Technical consulting

For when a technical decision has to be made and you have nobody to test it against.

02_Case: Lifeguard Health ApS_

8 years with Lifeguard

CTO & Co-Founder

From 2015 to 2023, I was CTO and co-founder of Lifeguard Health ApS. Here, I worked on the development of a digital health platform that combined technology, data and personal coaching. The role included everything from product development, UX and software architecture to management of development teams, operations and business development. The eight years at Lifeguard shaped my approach to both technology, products and people and today form the foundation for much of what I work with.

Watch Lifeguard's Core-story →

Lifeguard presentation_1_4_

Slides #1 showing my last job
Slides #2 showing my last job
Slides #3 showing my last job

03_Employment_history_

My experiences

From 1999 to 2026, I have worked in different roles with design, technology, and digital business. Here are 10 snapshots of that experience — the tasks I have solved, and the skills I have used along the way.

See them as cards, or explore periods and overlap on the timeline.

Experiences_

Image from my time at ESGRapporter

2024-2026, CTO & Co-founder

ESGRapporter

Now: ESGRapporter ApS.

We built the ESG reporting platform in Laravel, and I carried the technical responsibility for the direction, the reporting side and everyth ..

Image from my time at Revolvo

2024-2026, Senior Developer • UI/UX • Design

Revolvo

Now: Revolvo Aps. + BmyGuest ApS.

I handled development, UI/UX and graphic identity. 60% of my time went to BmyGuest and IDoMeetings, which Revolvo co-owned.

Image from my time at Lifeguard

2015-2023, CTO & Co-founder

Lifeguard

Now: Lifeguard Health ApS.

I built the LifeScore platform in Laravel with consent-based access to health data and an app for the wristband, and handled all UX and desi ..

Image from my time at VitalityGuard

2016-2018, CTO & Co-founder

VitalityGuard

Now: FIDIMI

We ran the Lifeguard platform white-labelled through a joint venture with Dansk Sundhedssikring. Maersk was the biggest client.

Image from my time at ContentCPH

2010-2015, Senior Digital Wizard

ContentCPH

Now: Charlie Tango

I built 60+ Facebook apps in PHP for Samsung, IKEA and H&M. The Nik & Jay campaign for Samsung won Danish Internet Awards 2014.

Image from my time at BOCCA WIRED

2009-2010, Freelance developer

BOCCA WIRED

Now: BOCCA

I built campaign sites for Movia and the Danish Heart Foundation, among them Overraskende hurtig, which took bronze at the Creative Circle A ..

Image from my time at EuroRSCG

2008-2010, Inhouse Freelance developer

EuroRSCG

Now: Havas Danmark

I won the agency's digital work back from the competitors and built an iPhone site and interactive product tools for GN/Jabra.

Image from my time at Makazilab

2005-2006, Co-founder & developer

Makazilab

Now: MIND SWITCH

Co-founder of Makazilab, where I built the technical side of three educational concepts on intelligence types, entrepreneurship and creativi ..

Image from my time at Bandits Inc.

1999-2026, Sole proprietorship

Bandits Inc.

Now: Audiotracking v/Paul Nybo Andersen

My own sole proprietorship since 1999. Through it I have sold web development to agencies that had the graphics but lacked the developer.

Image from my time at Audio Management

1999-2003, Co-founder & Digital Director

Audio Management

Now: Audiomanagement ApS

Co-founder of Audiomanagement, where we developed SoundIdentity® — sound branding and sound design for companies like Bang & Olufsen and bra ..

Now 2025 2020 2015 2010 2005 2000

Select an experience to read more

04_Skills + Stack_

My qualifications

As shown in the previous section, I have dealt with a wide range of tasks and taken on many different job roles, ranging from sound engineer to photographer, graphic artist, web developer, and CTO. The common feature in all of them has been my passion for creating meaningful experiences and my drive to create something unique.

In my approach, I have always been open to exploring new solutions to existing challenges, and I have never been afraid to acquire new knowledge. This has resulted in a wide range of skills that I have put together over time.

I have tried to list the most relevant ones here.

Rating

- " This is what I do best".

- " I'm pretty good at it".

- " I can do this just fine".

- " It's not what I'm best at, but I can if necessary".

- " I'm not good at it - but I'm willing to learn".

05_Writing_

Notes from the work

2026-10_

A good brief makes the invisible decisions visible

"I assumed that was included."

2026-09_

Should we build AI into our product?

"We need some AI in there." That might be the right call. I'd start by figuring out which problem the technology is actually meant to solve.

2026-09_

A good design doesn't start in Figma

I can open Figma and start drawing a website right away. It's rarely a good idea. Because before I know what the page should look like, I want to know what it should get someone to do.

2026-08_

What is technical SEO – and what isn't it?

When a page isn't found on Google, it's tempting to start with the copy. But before I'd change the content, I'd make sure Google can actually find the page, read it, and understand which version should show up in the search result. That's a large part of what technical SEO is about - technical problems can stand in the way of even good content.

2026-08_

What does a website cost?

– and why are two quotes almost impossible to compare?

2026-08_

Why is my website slow?

A slow website can be a 4 MB image. It can also be 10 other things. The first question isn't what the site is built in – it's where the time actually goes.

2026-06_

Which CMS should you choose?

WordPress, Umbraco, Drupal, Shopify, Webflow, or something else entirely? My slightly annoying answer is usually: What is it for?

2026-05_

A visual identity has to work without the designer

A visual identity is easy to make look good on a screen. It gets harder when it has to go out into the real world – into a PowerPoint, onto an invoice, onto a sign someone edits themselves three years later.

2026-05_

Is my job as a graphic designer under threat?

AI-generated graphics have moved out of the computer and into the real world. The question is no longer whether AI can make graphics. It can. The question is what is then left of the graphic designer's work.

2026-04_

When should you switch CMS?

Most people ask the wrong question first. The interesting one is not which CMS is best – it is whether the CMS is even the problem.

2026-04_

WordPress — the short version

The thing that makes WordPress easy to extend is also the reason behind most of the problems you meet in older installations.

2026-03_

WordPress vs. headless — the difference in practice

Headless gives you freedom by taking things apart. But whatever you take apart has to be put back together again.

2026-02_

Sometimes I design in VS Code

Not because I have given up on Figma. But because sometimes it is faster to see whether an idea holds up in the browser than on a canvas.

2026-01_

The most expensive code is the code you never had to write

Not all expensive code is bad code. Some of the most expensive decisions I have been part of were well-written solutions to problems nobody had yet.

2025-12_

From coder to reviewer – how AI changed the workflow

In the short term, AI does not change what I know – it changes my workflow.

2025-11_

The art of inheriting a WordPress installation

8 years, 34 plugins and a theme nobody dares touch. The job does not start by fixing anything – it starts by working out what is in use.

2025-08_

Ctrl, Cmd and C#

A language is learnable. It is the domain and the codebase that take time – and two machines that cost more attention than the syntax.

2025-02_

After a bankruptcy

Valued at 35 million at its height, bankrupt in December 2023, a new company seven months later. This is what sat in between – and what I took with me.

2024-11_

The report that had to sit in reception

When we built ESGRapporter, the competition had heavier calculation engines than we did. We bet somewhere else: on what the user was left holding being worth showing to someone.

06_When I'm not working_

A bit about me

I was born and raised in Copenhagen. But after a few years living with small children in an apartment in Østerbro, my girlfriend and I chose to move to a house in the suburb. We've lived in Hellerup for 11 years now, in a less pulsating neighborhood but no further away from Copenhagen than you can hop on the bike and then you're back.

I often do the latter; it's all about inspiration and new impressions. For the same reason, I still try to combine these trips with my passion for shooting photos. But since work has always been my hobby, it has been a challenge to find a balance between leisure and work projects.

When I'm not working, I spend a lot of time playing and listening to music. Unfortunately, over time, it has mostly become listening, which has been a very expensive but also rewarding passion.

The common feature of all my passions is the desire to create something. I hope this can benefit you.

TT38 profil

+25 years of experience with digital products ↓

Available for consulting, development, digital products and technical leadership.